Carol is swept off her feet when Jeff, an old friend of the Seaver family, returns to Long Island. She develops a crush on Jeff, and assumes that the feeling was mutual. But when Carol goes out to dinner with Jeff, the fact that he regards her as merely his "little sister" comes crashing down on her in dramatic fashion.
- Evan Arnold as Richie
- John Scott Clough as Jeffrey Backman
- Bader Howar as Leslie
- Wendy Wells-Gunkel as Protestor